St. Pete Times editorial
Published August 15, 2006

The Democratic field to succeed U.S. Rep. Jim Davis is rich with talent befitting the diverse, urban three-county 11th Congressional District. Of the five candidates in the Sept. 5 primary, two hold public office, four are lawyers, one is a former congressional aide and all have long been involved in community work. We give Hillsborough County Commissioner Kathy Castor the edge for her rounded experience and consistent record in pushing the right issues for the growing region.

Castor has been a strong voice of common sense since winning election to the commission four years ago. Through hard work and tactical savvy, Castor has blocked attempts by the Republican-dominated board to cut mass transit, ease growth restrictions and reduce health care for the poor. The 39-year-old lawyer's work at the state planning agency and Tampa Bay Water gives her a broad grasp of regional issues. Looking beyond parochialism is important in a House district that covers Tampa, parts of southern St. Petersburg and northern Manatee. Her familiarity with the legislative process complements an open, honest personal style that would be a breath of fresh air in Washington.

On policy matters, not much separates the candidates. Most call for withdrawing U.S. forces from Iraq and embrace traditional Democratic issues, from protecting the environment, privacy and abortion rights to assimilating illegal residents. The contrast is less about substance and more about style and relevant experience. State Sen. Les Miller of Tampa, who has represented much of the district over nearly two decades in state and local office, brings experience and leadership qualities to the table. Tampa attorney Scott Farrell, who lost a state House race in 2002, is a serious and articulate candidate who seems like a good fit for elected office. Attorneys Al Fox Jr. and Michael Steinberg, both of Tampa, contribute by hammering home the need for Congress to hold the executive branch accountable.

Castor's moralizing sometimes can put people off, but her priorities are right and she has the skills and energy to be a quick study and a forceful advocate. That's valuable to a freshman in an institution like Congress, where seniority and tradition are so important. It is a close call with such a field of solid candidates in the Democratic primary for the 11th Congressional District. The Times recommends Kathy Castor.